aipopdb

22 Nov 2026  ·  10,228 works · 1,193 news indexed

News / SAG-AFTRA chief says up to 15% of members want AI blocked

SAG-AFTRA chief says up to 15% of members want AI blocked

AIPopDB Newsroom · via hollywoodreporter.com · · 3 min read · Comment

Read the original ↗
Image for SAG-AFTRA chief says up to 15% of members want AI blocked

Image: Deadline

Watch on YouTube ↗

SAG-AFTRA's chief executive, Duncan Crabtree-Ireland, told a Web Summit audience in Lisbon on 12 November that the union accepts AI cannot be stopped, and that its job is to set ground rules so performers and the technology can coexist. He spoke in a session titled "Hollywood's Identity Crisis", moderated by Deadline's Stewart Clarke, next to Dan Neely, co-founder and CEO of Vermillio. The session had been moved to the conference's third day after storm Charles cancelled the second.

“Some of our members would like us to block it. I hear from them every day, and they're angry that we aren't”

Duncan Crabtree-Ireland, SAG-AFTRA national executive director and CEO, at Web Summit · hollywoodreporter.com ↗

Asked what share of the union's roughly 160,000 members would like AI blocked outright, Crabtree-Ireland put it at about 10 percent, perhaps 15, and stressed that this was his own estimate. He said some of them contact him daily, unhappy that the union has not done more. Others, he said, want AI tools to help their craft but none want to be replaced by them. He also drew a line between fully synthetic characters, which he said are not people, and AI copies of real performers. Tilly Norwood, the AI-generated performer, had been on the same main stage earlier in the week.

The union's framework rests on three principles: consent, control and compensation. For a digital replica, he said, the test is whether an audience would perceive it as a particular person's voice or look, a lower bar than the percentage scoring Vermillio is building. Neely described that technology as able to say how much of a voice belongs to whom, for example 30 percent one person, 30 percent another and 40 percent original, and expects far more clarity on measuring likeness within twelve months. Vermillio is a licensing and protection platform that detects unauthorised uses of people's likenesses.

Lead picture The Hollywood Reporter ran with its report on the Web Summit session

Lead picture The Hollywood Reporter ran with its report on the Web Summit session

Image: The Hollywood Reporter

Crabtree-Ireland said that when performers' likenesses are misused, they mostly want the content removed rather than money, and that takedowns are the point in the vast majority of cases, over 90 percent. He recalled his own likeness being misused during the 2023 strike, which remains the union's reference point on AI; he cited a picket sign from then reading "ChatGPT doesn't have childhood trauma". Neely argued that bad actors use a well-known actor's likeness to attach themselves to an existing fandom, which is why abuse is so common, and said consent can be arranged afterwards with guardrails.

About SAG-AFTRA

SAG-AFTRA is the US trade union for screen actors, broadcasters and other performers, based in Los Angeles. It was formed on 30 March 2012 by the merger of the Screen Actors Guild and the American Federation of Television and Radio Artists.

This is not its first fight over synthetic likenesses. In 2018 the union began pushing back against unregulated face-swapping technology that infringes members' rights, and says it seeks to regulate deepfakes through contracts and legislation. Its 2023 strike, in which AI was an issue, lasted almost four months and ended on 9 November 2023; the deal, ratified on 5 December with 78.33% approval, included protection against AI use of actors' images. From 26 July 2024 it also struck video game companies over the replication of voices and likenesses without consent or fair pay; the strike was suspended on 11 June 2025 and a deal ratified on 9 July 2025.

The panel also pointed to Scarlett Johansson's dispute with OpenAI, after she threatened legal action over a voice that sounded like hers. OpenAI pulled the voice without conceding it was modelled on her. The proposed NO FAKES Act, which would protect a person's voice and visual likeness from unauthorised digital replicas, with a UK counterpart, is still working its way through Congress.

Comments