A short animation posted to X on September 26 by the artist Antrofrog went viral, and viewers quickly concluded it had been made with AI. Much of the response was hostile, reflecting the particular resistance AI faces in animation over jobs and copyright.
Set to Sade's "Smooth Operator", it follows a tall man with an umbrella strolling through a city, catching falling flowerpots and rescuing cats from trees with a deadpan air. At first glance it is a light, harmless piece.
Creative Bloq says the giveaway was a mix of styles that do not belong together: an anime-looking lead dropped into a classic Disney setting, surrounded by figures resembling picture-book art and old New Yorker cartoons. Some viewers said designs looked lifted, with one asking whether a boy was Ben from Cartoon Saloon's Song of the Sea. Another suggested that since AI output has no copyright, human artists should simply take the umbrella man's design for themselves.
Others picked at the storytelling, such as a stolen bag handed to a woman who already carried one and the hero pushing a child on a scooter into the road. One commenter said AI's real cost was forcing audiences to doubt whether any gesture or pause was intended, which kills the magic.
Creative Bloq calls the criticism fair and says more accessible tools raise the question of whether prompt-based work can stand alongside art made by hand.
Sources · 1