aipopdb

22 Nov 2026  ·  10,228 works · 1,193 news indexed

News / BPI tells the Court of Appeal that the Getty v Stability ruling could let AI firms train offshore and sell in the UK

BPI tells the Court of Appeal that the Getty v Stability ruling could let AI firms train offshore and sell in the UK

AIPopDB Newsroom · via completemusicupdate.com · · 3 min read · Comment · United Kingdom

Read the original ↗
Image for BPI tells the Court of Appeal that the Getty v Stability ruling could let AI firms train offshore and sell in the UK

Image: Complete Music Update

Watch on YouTube ↗

Getty Images' appeal against last year's High Court ruling on Stability AI was heard by the Court of Appeal on Wednesday and Thursday this week. The UK record industry body BPI took part as an intervener on Getty's side, warning the judges that the outcome could carry "significant consequences" for music and the wider creative industries.

The question before the court is narrow but important: if a model is trained on unlicensed material in another country and then made available in Britain, does it infringe UK copyright even though the copying happened abroad? Getty dropped its primary infringement claims about two weeks into the June 2025 trial, because the training took place outside the UK and it was agreed that the model holds no copies of images. That left secondary infringement, which requires importing and selling an "article" that is an "infringing copy", a rule usually applied to physical goods such as CDs pressed overseas.

Mrs Justice Joanna Smith found that the model was not an infringing copy. Getty won only in part, on trade mark claims over older models and isolated examples. At the appeal, Getty argued that a model trained abroad can still be an infringing copy when brought into the UK, even if it stores no images. Stability AI replied that training and storage took place in data centres outside Britain, so UK copyright does not reach them, and that widening liability is a job for Parliament rather than the courts.

BPI's concern is that leaving the High Court's reading in place would suggest AI companies can train offshore to sidestep British rules and still sell their products at home. It said most of the music and copyright industries think the same principle should apply to models trained abroad and sold in the UK, wherever the training happened. It also stressed that future UK claims might not rest on this argument, pointing to German courts that found models contained copies through "memorisation" in GEMA's cases against OpenAI and Suno. Lawyer Harry Jewson of Burges Salmon said BPI wants the Getty judgment treated as having "no wider significance" for whether models contain copies, a point that depends on each model.

Photo illustration for City AM's report on Getty's challenge to the Stability AI ruling

Photo illustration for City AM's report on Getty's challenge to the Stability AI ruling

Thomas Fuller/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images · Image: City AM

Getty's barrister told the court that its "very sophisticated database" makes its content desirable for AI training. Getty declined to comment, and Stability AI, whose directors include filmmaker James Cameron, was approached for comment. The appeal comes as Getty has filed for US bankruptcy to restructure and go private, after its $3.7bn merger with Shutterstock was abandoned in July following scrutiny from Britain's competition regulator.

About BPI

BPI is the trade body for British record companies. It was formally incorporated in 1973 to promote British music and fight copyright infringement, and it runs the BRIT Awards, which it founded in 1977, and the Mercury Prize. It also awards BRIT Certified sales and co-owns the Official Charts Company with the Entertainment Retailers Association.

This is not the first time BPI has taken a stand on AI and copyright. In February 2025 it urged its members and others to respond to the UK government's consultation, opposing the preferred option of a text and data mining exception with a rights-holder opt-out. Its chief executive Jo Twist said UK law is not uncertain and does not allow commercial text and data mining without a licence, and warned that the government's AI proposals risked destroying the UK's status as a creative superpower.

A Court of Appeal ruling is expected towards the end of this year or in early 2027. An earlier call for change came from the All Party Parliamentary Group for Music, which proposed in its 2024 AI report that UK copyright law be amended to cover offshore training.

Comments