Advocate General Maciej Szpunar of the EU Court of Justice delivered his non-binding opinion on 3 November 2026 in Case C-250/25, Like Company v Google Ireland. It is the first generative-AI copyright case to reach the court. His main view is that a chatbot which retrieves online press articles and reuses them in real time to answer questions may, in certain circumstances, infringe press publishers' rights. The judges have begun deliberating, and a judgment will follow at a later date. They tend to follow their Advocates General, but they are not bound to.
The dispute began with Like Company, a Hungarian web-portal operator, which sued Google in the Budapest Regional Court over its Bard chatbot and then Gemini. The infringement ran from 13 June 2023 to 31 May 2024, and it says Google reproduced its articles and made them available to the public through the chatbot without permission or payment. It relies only on the press publishers' right in Article 15 of the 2019 copyright directive, not on ordinary copyright. Its example is a July 2023 article about a singer's plan to bring freshwater dolphins to Lake Balaton. Asked to summarise it, Gemini added details the article lacked, including a pool of 25 by 15 metres on the Tihany peninsula. Google's position is that leaving articles freely online amounts to implied consent, and that invented details are hallucinations.
The Hungarian court sent four questions, two on training a language model and two on chatbot answers. Szpunar called the training questions inadmissible and hypothetical, since nothing shows the articles were used to train Gemini: the article dates from July 2023 and Gemini 1.0 arrived in December 2023. He still gave a view. Training involves copying, but the text-and-data-mining exception generally covers it, commercial models included, provided access was lawful and the publisher has not set a machine-readable opt-out.
The retrieval side is where he sees the real issue. A chatbot reproduces an article if it accessed it unlawfully, for instance by getting round a paywall or anti-scraping measure, or if its answer keeps the article's recognisable form of expression so that, in a side-by-side comparison, a reader need not consult the original. Summarising the same facts, or building an answer from several sources, is not reproduction, even when it costs the publisher a click. In his words, the right does not subsist in mere facts. It is meant to protect the investment in producing a publication, not to give a monopoly over the news. Making the work available to the public is infringed, as a rule, only when recognisable expression appears systematically across answers to related queries; a single output is not enough.
On responsibility, the user who asks the question is the immediate trigger. The provider is liable where infringing reuse is inherent in its business model, or where it fails to take measures a diligent operator would, such as honouring access limits and filtering near-copies. He also rejects the idea that open access means consent, since publishers keep pages free for advertising revenue and search visibility.
About Gemini
Gemini is Google's generative AI chatbot and virtual assistant, developed by Google AI and Google DeepMind and powered by the Gemini family of large language models. It began life as Bard, which Google opened to early-access users in the United States and the United Kingdom through a waitlist on 21 March 2023.
In September 2023 Google introduced the Google-Extended crawler token, which lets web publishers opt out of having Bard scan their sites for training. Google announced the Gemini language model on 6 December 2023, and on 8 February 2024 it brought Bard and Duet AI together under the Gemini name, alongside a mobile app.
Applied to this case, the opinion suggests Like Company is likely to lose, subject to the Budapest court's findings. There was apparently no paywall or bot block, the dolphin answer did not clearly copy the article's wording, and Google appeared to have mitigation measures in place. The Court of Justice has not set a date for its judgment, and the Hungarian court will make the final findings on whether Google crossed the lines.

Comments