aipopdb

22 Nov 2026  ·  10,137 works · 1,192 news indexed

News / Universal and Sony oppose Suno's bid to freeze their second lawsuit

Universal and Sony oppose Suno's bid to freeze their second lawsuit

AIPopDB Newsroom · via musicbusinessworldwide.com · · 4 min read · Comment

Read the original ↗
Image for Universal and Sony oppose Suno's bid to freeze their second lawsuit

4300streetcar · Image: Digital Music News

Watch on YouTube ↗

Universal Music Group and Sony Music have told a Boston federal court they will not accept a complete freeze of their second copyright lawsuit against Suno. In a 17-page filing made on Friday 13 November, the two labels said they could live with a narrow pause, which they called a partial stay, but not with shelving the whole case while the AI music company keeps building and selling new models.

Suno asked Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV on 30 October to hold the second case until he decides summary judgment in the first one, which the labels brought in June 2024. The second suit was filed on 18 September 2026 and covers 60,202 recordings, against 560 in the first. With statutory damages of up to $150,000 a work for wilful infringement, the theoretical ceiling is a little over $9bn. The cases are numbered 1:24-cv-11611 and 1:26-cv-14275. Discovery on the stream-ripping claims in the first case runs to 20 November 2026, but summary judgment motions there are not due until 22 June 2027, so the labels argue a full stay could leave their newer case frozen into 2028 and keep Suno's 2025 and 2026 models, v6 included, out of any examination until then.

“Delay would not merely postpone building the record, it would degrade it”

Universal Music Group and Sony Music Entertainment, in their court filing · musicbusinessworldwide.com ↗

Suno's reasoning is efficiency. It says pausing avoids two overlapping cases, and that a ruling in the first, on whether its conduct was fair use or whether YouTube's technical protections can support a claim under Section 1201(a), could knock out the labels' theories in the second. It also argues that Judge Saylor had already contemplated a stay; the labels reply that it was one option among several, consolidation among them. Both sides, in other words, read the same earlier hearing differently, and the judge has yet to say which reading he shares.

What the labels would accept is a pause on proving they own the 60,000-plus recordings. They want discovery on the newer models to start now: v6 training, Suno's licensing efforts, new businesses and funding rounds including investor pitches, and its recent finances. Suno raised more than $400m at a $5.4bn valuation in June and reports annual revenue in the hundreds of millions. The labels say its document handover in the first case largely stops at February 2025, that nobody has explained how v6 was trained, and that the engineer in charge of data scraping has left, so delay would erode the evidence. They also say a Justice Department filing Suno cited, from the OpenAI newspaper case, does not bear on a creative entertainment platform.

If the judge does grant a wider stay, the labels ask for conditions: use of the first case's record straight away, an order for Suno to preserve its training data and every model version, a status report within 14 days, and an automatic end to the stay once the summary judgment ruling lands. In return they offer to share evidence about the market for licensing AI training data and about how AI music affects the value of recordings.

The labels also stress who bears the cost of waiting. A full stay, they say, would let Suno go on training, releasing, licensing and monetising models that nobody has independently scrutinised, and it would lengthen the life of both cases on the court's docket rather than shorten it. Their reasoning is that engineers who built v6 may leave and training pipelines change over time, so evidence gets worse the longer it sits. That is why they ask for preservation of the training data and each model version in any version of a stay.

Suno
AI company

About Suno

The three major labels sued Suno, along with Udio, in June 2024, accusing it of copying recordings on a massive scale to train its models; the first case named 560 works as examples. Warner Music announced on 25 November 2025 that it had settled and signed a licensing partnership with Suno. Earlier that month, on 4 November, the Danish collecting society Koda sued Suno in Copenhagen City Court.

On 21 May 2026 Universal and Sony moved to add 61,026 recordings to the first suit, which they said audio fingerprinting had found in Suno's training data. That attempt to widen the first case is how the labels' second lawsuit came about.

2022

Founded

1

Works credited

4

Models indexed

Models on AIPopDB

H3 Move
Suno Speech
Suno Studio
Suno v5
See Suno on AIPopDB

The fight sits among several side disputes. Subpoena battles in the first case involve Nvidia, the Mechanical Licensing Collective, Suno's investors, Apple and DistroKid. Judge Saylor refused on 18 August to add 61,026 more recordings to the first case, saying it would cause delay, but pointed the labels to a separate suit. Warner Music settled and licensed Suno in November 2025, and Suno launched v6 on 9 September saying it was built with Warner, BMG and Believe. Elvis Presley Enterprises and Eight Mile Style brought further suits against the company on 6 November. The labels sum up their objection by saying the stay Suno wants would leave discovery on the key issues going nowhere. Their proposal is a middle course: ownership questions wait, while the evidence about newer models, money and licensing starts to flow now. Judge Saylor has not ruled on the stay, and no decision had been reported as of 17 November.

Comments